ŷ

Melanie's Reviews > A Court of Frost and Starlight

A Court of Frost and Starlight by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3030788
's review

liked it
bookshelves: fae, fantasy, magic, new-adult, romance, signed, read-in-2018, novellas, steamy-scenes, read-in-2023, holiday
Read 2 times. Last read December 25, 2023 to December 26, 2023.

1.) A Court of Thorns and Roses ★★★★
2.) A Court of Mist and Fury ★★�
3.) A Court of Wings and Ruin ★★�

[2023 reread] ★★�
i really wanted to reread this this year, because i was reminded that it was set during the winter holiday season, and truly? this was a really nice reread. it does start on the first day of winter, which also happens to be feyre’s birthday! (i had very much forgotten that she was only 21, which did send me into a spiral of my own!) but we get to see her and the inner circle celebrate that and celebrate winter solstice together.

this long novella really is the bridging book to A ​Court of Silver Flames and i actually think it does a very good job prepping what is to come. we even get to see in cassian and nesta pov at the very end, which i had forgotten completely. but ultimately this really is a story about ptsd and grief and how those things look so very different in so many people. People experience things differently, people choose to show others how they are feeling differently, and people heal differently. i actually think this book does a very good job showing that and celebrating that in it’s own respectful way.

i for sure think i appreciated this more the second time around! also, sjm just really knows how to write a cold atmosphere and winter setting, and the timing of this just really made for a good reading experience. i can’t wait to finally finish this series reread, leading up to
House of Flame and Shadow
!

trigger + content warnings: a lot of talk of loss of loved ones in the past, talk of war, talk of murder and death, grief depiction, ptsd depiction, misogyny and sexism, extreme abuse in past / violence against women, talk of menstruation and painful/hard menstrual cycles, gore and violence in past, talk of weight loss, blood, animal death.

[2018 first read] ★★�


“The first snow of winter had begun whipping through Velaris...�



| | | | |
511 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Court of Frost and Starlight.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 15, 2017 – Shelved
August 15, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
August 15, 2017 – Shelved as: fae
August 15, 2017 – Shelved as: fantasy
August 15, 2017 – Shelved as: magic
August 15, 2017 – Shelved as: new-adult
August 15, 2017 – Shelved as: romance
February 8, 2018 – Shelved as: signed
April 14, 2018 – Shelved as: read-in-2018
April 14, 2018 – Shelved as: novellas
April 30, 2018 – Started Reading
May 1, 2018 – Shelved as: steamy-scenes
May 1, 2018 – Finished Reading
December 25, 2023 – Started Reading
December 25, 2023 – Shelved as: read-in-2023
December 26, 2023 – Finished Reading
November 19, 2024 – Shelved as: holiday

Comments Showing 1-50 of 89 (89 new)


message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

COVER REVEAL!




message 2: by Zain (new) - added it

Zain Otoom Nesta sure looks a lot like Feyre on this covet.
I LOVE THIS I LOVE NESTA 😂💙


Bitchin' Reads XD XD I am loving your updates!


message 4: by SassyFraz (new) - added it

SassyFraz that is feyre. nesta hasn't gotten her book yet


Melanie SassyFraz wrote: "that is feyre. nesta hasn't gotten her book yet"




♛ may hahahahahahhahahahaha
i love this


Wren (fablesandwren) GOSH MELANIE, CAN’T YOU SEE THAT IT FEYRE?


Vignesh Kumar That's Feyre!! Not Nesta


message 10: by SassyFraz (new) - added it

SassyFraz Melanie wrote: "SassyFraz wrote: "that is feyre. nesta hasn't gotten her book yet"

"


LMBO!


message 11: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie ahahaha melanie. you're too great. PS why are these covers getting uglier and uglier? She looks so STIFF and the whole composition is just BAD. ugh. I hate this already. Your review will be my only exposure to this book


Melanie @ everyone - i love you all 💘xo


Melanie Stephanie wrote: "ahahaha melanie. you're too great. PS why are these covers getting uglier and uglier? She looks so STIFF and the whole composition is just BAD. ugh. I hate this already. Your review will be my only..."

They truly are getting worse! But those three stars by her hand? I'M CONSPIRACY THEORY THINKING OF A PREGNANCY! True? And oh my gosh, no pressure, right? Haha! I hope you've been well, beautiful! 💘xx


message 14: by Jessica (new)

Jessica I just saw your "review" on this and I love it to pieces! So funny!


Ivusha (Tenebien) To your latest update: Well, they are sisters. Duh. :D


Melanie Jessica wrote: "I just saw your "review" on this and I love it to pieces! So funny!"

💘 ilysm, Jess!


Melanie Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "To your latest update: Well, they are sisters. Duh. :D"

RIGHT? 💘xx


message 18: by Lema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lema YOU SPEAK TO MY SOUL!


Ivusha (Tenebien) Melanie, but yeah, can't wait for Nesta and Cassian to get their own story. 😍


Melanie Lema wrote: "YOU SPEAK TO MY SOUL!"

Hehehe! 💘xx


Melanie Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "Melanie, but yeah, can't wait for Nesta and Cassian to get their own story. 😍"

Same, love! I hope this is the perfect bridge book to give us the book of our dreams! Haha. 💘xx


Ivusha (Tenebien) Melanie wrote: "Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "Melanie, but yeah, can't wait for Nesta and Cassian to get their own story. 😍"

Same, love! I hope this is the perfect bridge book to give us the book of our dreams! Haha...."


Yeah, I've wanted that book ever since they met for the first time. :D


Melanie Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "Melanie wrote: "Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "Melanie, but yeah, can't wait for Nesta and Cassian to get their own story. 😍"

Same, love! I hope this is the perfect bridge book to give us the book of o..."


LESS THAN A MONTH! Can you believe it? Ahhhh! So excited! 💘xx


Ivusha (Tenebien) Melanie wrote: "Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "Melanie wrote: "Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "Melanie, but yeah, can't wait for Nesta and Cassian to get their own story. 😍"

Same, love! I hope this is the perfect bridge boo..."


I can't wait, actually! A Court of Wings and Ruin got published in Czech like 2 weeks ago, so everybody here is going through the craze right now. :D I see posts about the book on Instagram, Facebook, and Czech book pages all the time. And I'm like: GIMME FROST AND STARLIGHT! :D


message 25: by Shay (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shay Wait a second. Different places in the world get books that far after we did? That is just wrong.


Ivusha (Tenebien) Worst of all - majority of my favorite books haven't been published at all! I really have to get a job with some publisher. 😀


Samira I am so excited!!!


Serenity So excited for this! Have you pre-ordered? Asking because I can't decide where I should pre-order from. I think this time only Books-a-Million has a special edition (with the artwork), but I can't decide if I want to get it from there because it's a bit out of my way, whereas if I order from Amazon I can get it delivered right to my door on the day of lol (and it's cheaper).


Mary ~Ravager of Tomes~ Awh dang it's such a shame I am not in this fandom because I love the Enamel Pin 😂


Melanie Samira wrote: "I am so excited!!!"

I am too, Samira! Ahhhh! All the feels! 💖xx


Melanie The Story Girl wrote: "So excited for this! Have you pre-ordered? Asking because I can't decide where I should pre-order from. I think this time only Books-a-Million has a special edition (with the artwork), but I can't ..."

I did preorder, love! But I put in my order through Good Choice Reading so that I could get it signed. BUT if I didn't, I would have totally preordered the BAM edition for those end pages! But I don't know the price difference. I'm also super cheap! Haha! Regardless, I can't wait to see what you pick! And I can't wait to see what we all think! 💖xx


Melanie Mary ~Ravager of Tomes~ wrote: "Awh dang it's such a shame I am not in this fandom because I love the Enamel Pin 😂"

Hahaha! Very true, beautiful! If I come across a second one, I'll send it to you! 💖xx


message 33: by Lila (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lila I'm dying. my preorder better not take forever to get here 😂😂😂


Melanie Tiffany wrote: "I'm dying. my preorder better not take forever to get here 😂😂😂"

Same, love, SAME! Happy reading, Tiffany! 💖xx


message 35: by Lila (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lila happy reading to you! 🖤


Brianna So have you got your pin yet? I preordered months ago and submitted my proof of purchase but haven’t even received a confirmation of the pin to arrive.


Melanie Bree wrote: "So have you got your pin yet? I preordered months ago and submitted my proof of purchase but haven’t even received a confirmation of the pin to arrive."

I haven't! But don't worry, I normally get SJM swag a little over two weeks after the book releases! 💖xx


Kayla Brunson Wonderful review babe! Also, you know I’m a perv so I can’t wait to read all those scenes lol


Michelle (Witchy Books) Great review. :) Sadly my copy isn't coming in the mail till the 11th of may...that's what i get for per-ordering from amazon


message 40: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Curie Ah man, I kind of wish she had let these characters go before it'd feel like she'd need 200+ pages of fan service...


Ivusha (Tenebien) Okay, will read the rest AFTER I read the book. :D


Sol ~ TheBookishKing ”At this point, it feels like SJM is beating the deadest of horses that have ever died.�

you’re an Icon 😂😍 loved the Review Mels and agree with everything 🙌🏽


Melanie Kayla wrote: "Wonderful review babe! Also, you know I’m a perv so I can’t wait to read all those scenes lol"

Awh, thank you, gorgeous! I can't wait to gush with you about it later this week! And girl, you know I'm the biggest of pervs, let's be real. Hehe. Happy reading, love! 💖xx


Melanie Michelle wrote: "Great review. :) Sadly my copy isn't coming in the mail till the 11th of may...that's what i get for per-ordering from amazon"

Awh, I'm sorry, love! Yeah... my copy said it wasn't going to arrive until the 5th, so I couldn't resist buying the ebook at midnight! BUT I hope you love this one, Michelle! Happy reading! 💖xx


Melanie Michelle wrote: "Ah man, I kind of wish she had let these characters go before it'd feel like she'd need 200+ pages of fan service..."

Girl, 100% yes to this. 💖xx


Melanie Ivusha (Tenebien) wrote: "Okay, will read the rest AFTER I read the book. :D"

Hehe! I hope you enjoy, Ivusha! Happy reading, beautiful! And I can't wait to talk to you after! 💖xx


Melanie Solomon S. wrote: "”At this point, it feels like SJM is beating the deadest of horses that have ever died.�

you’re an Icon 😂😍 loved the Review Mels and agree with everything 🙌🏽"


You're my favorite and I love and miss you! 💖xx


message 48: by Mel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mel Anie Great review, Melanie. I cannot wait to read this one. US edition looks wat nicer in my opinion.


Melanie Mel wrote: "Great review, Melanie. I cannot wait to read this one. US edition looks wat nicer in my opinion."

Thank you so much, Mel! I can't wait to gush with you about this! Happy reading, love! 💖xx


message 50: by clara (new) - rated it 1 star

clara amazing review, melanie!

i'm so glad that someone else feels the same way about tamlin - yeah, he did a lot of shitty things and that should never be forgotten nor excused, but i honestly think he's one of the more interesting characters to read about, especially in comparison with (the blander) rhys and feyre.


« previous 1
back to top